nenena: (Soul Eater - Soul/Maka)
nenena ([personal profile] nenena) wrote2011-08-11 07:29 pm

Soul Eater Chapter 89: You put your right hand in, you put your right hand out.

You put your left hand in
But don't shake it all about!
You didn't do that with your right hand
And symmetry is really key

That's what it's all about!




So, anyway. We open with the Spartoi kids all sitting around and making Grimdark Serious faces, except for Harvar who is just wearing his normal facial expression.

"So they want us to be the ones to execute Crona..." Soul says.

Maka orally molests some ellipses.

"That's completely heartless, even by Shinigami-sama's standards," Kim objects. "No matter what Crona may have done, to give the execution order specifically to Maka's team is..."

"But I wouldn't want Crona to be dealt with in some other way without us ever knowing about it," Maka answers. "We might still be able to..."

She grits her teeth. "I don't know what to do... But I don't think it's too late..."

And then the Troika finally show up. "Sorry... We just got back."

"We heard the news," Liz says.

Kim immediately confronts Kid. "Kid! You're a shinigami, aren't you?! So you can go and tell Shinigami-sama that he's out of his freakin' mind! Ordering Maka's team to execute Crona is too cruel! And Crona might still be being manipulated by Medusa, so ordering an execution is... Anyway, we don't have enough information to justify an execution!"

Kid hesitates for a moment, then answers, "What Crona has done is unforgivable."

Maka finally lets slip her sad face.

"The death scythe Tsar and his partner Fyodor were, for all intents and purposes, murdered by Crona," Kid goes on. Well, uh, thank you for clearing that up, Ohkubo! Although I think what happened to Fyodor and Tsar technically counts as a Fate Worse Than Death rather than a simple murder, but who's nitpicking here? "And then Crona swallowed up an entire city's population in a black sphere of madness," Kid continues. "Crona's death sentence is inevitable."

Black Star suddenly grabs Kid by the collar. "Did you come all the way over here just to spout that boring shit?!" Black Star shouts.

Kid responds to this affront of his personal space bubble by punching Black Star in the chin. "Learn to listen all the way until the other person is finished talking," Kid says. "Anyway. I was also going to say that there is no such thing as an absolute, unbendable law." That was the right thing to say. Wasn't it, Eibon...?

"But..." Harvar interjects. "Even within the same nation you'll find different races of people holding different values. Just looks at us, just the Spartoi members in this room. The only thing binding all of these different people together are the laws that they must follow, right? Even a rational person like me can lose his head sometimes. That is a universal human weakness." Aaaaaand we have a flashback panel of Harvar stabbing Kim in the chest. "We have order not because of human rationality, but because we have rules and laws. Shinigami are the symbol of the law. If you start obscuring the law and acting mealy-mouthed about its enforcement, human civilization will descend into chaos."

Ah, the good ol' slippery slope fallacy. Harvar, were you just born with that stick lightning rod up your ass?

Come on, Kid. Answer that one. Answer that one good. The former debate coach within me wants you to point out that Big Daddy bends rules all the freakin' time (i.e. taking in Crona, taking in Angela, making deals with Medusa, etc.) and that so far this has not caused human civilization to descend into anarchy and madness. That's Asura's fault, not Big Daddy's fault. But let's see what Kid can come up with to respond to Harvar.

"But there are those who have not yet agreed with the order to execute Crona," Kid responds. "Father may have given an order of execution on paper, but what I think he really wants us to do is to make our own decision about how we should deal with somebody who's unbound by rules like Crona. That was why he gave the execution order special to our Spartoi team. We're never going to advance in any meaningful way if all we do is keep our heads down and follow orders blindly."

"Now he's finally starting to sound like a good man," Liz says, making mooney eyes at Kid.

"So that's why we have to search for Crona right away," Kid goes on.

Meanwhile, Maka is making fists on her legs and staring off grimly into space. I have to be the first one of us to talk to Crona. I have to find Crona before anybody else does! She turns to Soul. "Soul, will you help me?"

Later! It's night, apparently, and Soul and Maka are standing on a high balcony somewhere on the Shibusen building. "Maka," Soul says, because I guess he needs to have at least one word bubble in this chapter.

"I'm going to use the full extent of my soul perception to search for Crona..."

And then, OTP SPARKLE POWER. I can feel my awareness covering the entire Earth. Soul's piano connects me to the entire world...

And he's playing the piano on her shoulders, apparently. Maka Albarn: Human Instrumentality.

And, pop!

Soul's soul---... And my soul---...

Now everybody's souls---...

Crona...

I'll just follow the insanity and...

I can see the whole world, and I WILL find you!

Are you here?

Are you here?

Are you here?

Are you here?

Are you here?

Are you here?

Are you here?

Are you here?

Are you here?

Are you here?

Boy I hope y'all following along at home can see that an image of Excalibur is repeated three times (oddly sans any thought-bubble narration from Maka) during this search sequence. Three being a deeply symbolic number in this manga and all.

Are you here?

Are you here?

Are you here?

Are you here?

Are you here?

Are you here?

Are you here?

Are you here?

And, whoops. Following the trail of insanity didn't lead Maka to Crona at all. Instead she seems to have found a much, much bigger fish to fry.

THE MOON?!

Maka stares up at the moon as it drools blood on her face. I love you, Ohkubo.

"What's wrong, Maka?" Soul asks. "Did you find Crona?"

"No... I found the kishin..."

Meanwhile, JESUS TAPDANCING CHRIST IT'S HORRORCORE TEZCA! Who is floating in Big Daddy's mirror. "The kishin is most likely hiding on the moon," Tezca reports.

The adults and Kid are "!!" upon hearing this news. Even though the rest of us in the fandom figured it out last month.

"Is that true?" Big Daddy asks. Which is probably the wrong question to be asking when one of your top agents whom you thought had turned traitor and dissappeared without a trace suddenly shows up dead and gory in your mirror. But Big Daddy has always kind of spectacularly failed at these basic social interactions (remember "HEY KIDS THERE'S A KISHIN SEALED IN THE BASEMENT! Okay carry on with your party now"?), so I guess this isn't surprising.

"When I was pursuin' Justin's soul, at one point I did feel a faint wavelength comin' from the moon... By the way, Justin kinda murdered my physical body. But I can still reflect my soul in a mirror. So I came here to tell ya about the moon thing."

Goddamn Tezca that is one buttfuckingugly soul you've got there.

Suddenly, Maka! "SHINIGAMI-SAMA!! I know where the kishin Asura is!!"

Hey, I bet that makes Tezca feel real swell. Now that he's died for no reason and all.

But hey, it's not like Ohkubo is going to show anybody caring - or even reacting whatsoever - to the news that Tezca is dead. Nope. Instead we're going to get a brief time skip indicated by a blank panel, and then Shinigami-sama saying, "So Maka-chan felt the kishin's presence on the moon with her soul perception too, huh..."

"Very impressive, Maka-chan!" Marie says with a smile.

"Not really... I was actually searching for Crona, and I just sort of accidentally found the kishin... And I only thought to look up there because I felt a high concentration of insanity in the upper atmosphere during our whale hunt..."

"The possibility that the kishin is hiding himself on the moon has just become a high likelihood," Sid declares. So I guess Stein was the one who sewed back on his arm, judging from the stitches.

"What should we do?" Nygus asks. Has she worn that black dress before? It looks pretty great on her.

"Well, it was my daughter Maka who found the kishin for us," Spirit says, "And it's thanks to my daughter that we know where the kishin is." Thank you, Captain Redundant! "Since it was my daughter who did all of the work, Papa just can't be left behind on this mission, right? I mean, for my daughter's sake and all."

Oh god Maka's face. Spirit totally deserves that reaction, though. Not only is his entire speech bubble both nonsensical and somehow completely gross at the same time, but TEZCA ALSO FOUND THE KISHIN AND PAID FOR IT WITH HIS LIFE. And isn't Tezca's soul like still right there next to Spirit? Jesus!

"Let's prepare for a final battle against the kishin," Stein says. "First, we need to call together all of the Death Scythes."

"I should..." Kid begins.

"Kid should be taken off the Spartoi's current mission and join the battle against the kishin," Stein says. "What do you think, Shinigami-sama?"

"That's right," Shinigami-sama says. "If there ends up being a battle on the moon, it will inevitably turn into an aerial battle---... So we're gonna need Kid's skateboard-fu."

Yes, he really said that. That's the closest English equivalent I can give you of Kid no skateboard-teku. Maybe "skateboard-no-jutsu" if you want to get really silly with the translation.

"But more importantly..." Shinigami-sama says. "This is a fight to re-establish 'order' in the world."

Kid looks grimserious, then he turns to Maka and Soul. "Maka. Soul. I agree with this decision... I'm sorry." He goes on, apparently needing to justify himself for four more word bubbles. "Father cannot go to the moon. As a shinigami, this is a battle that I must fight. This may be irresponsible of me, but Maka... You have to be the one who stops Crona... So I leave Crona up to you."

"I know. I understand..." Maka says. "I didn't want you on my mission anyway. All you do is get yourself kidnapped and make Black Star act all weird and homoerotic around you. And you'd probably shoot Crona first and ask questions later anyway, because your character development is shallow and artificial and also because you're still a giant dick."

"Your mission is definitely the more dangerous one," Soul says to Kid. "So, you know, don't die or anything."

Kid laughs. "If I die, then Black Star is going to be pretty pissed off at me." Then, more seriously (and recycling artwork from a previous panel to indicate this serious GODDAMN OHKUBO THAT IS SOME ECONOMICAL ARTISTRY YOU'VE GOT GOING ON HERE): "There is no question that he is absolutely the strongest at Shibusen right now. Which I find oddly vexing... I suppose that this must have been the emotion that was driving Black Star before now." Kid makes a resolute fist. "But I can still become much stronger than I am now! I'll definitely surpass him again!"

Soul rolls his eyes. "Kid..."

"Do NOT repeat a word of that to Black Star," Kid says, threatening Soul with a raised finger. "It will make him insufferably cocky."

"Okay," Soul says, fist-bumping Kid. "I gotcha."

Kid stares at the fist that Soul bumped and chews on some ellipses.

Finally he holds out his other fist. "Do my left hand too," he demands.

"Geez..." Soul says as he obligingly bumps Kid's other fist. "Guess you haven't changed that much after all."

Later, when the kids and the other adults are gone, Spirit and Big Daddy are alone in front of Big Daddy's mirror.

Big Daddy sighs. Which is really impressive, because he has no mouth.

"You're impatient, aren't you," Spirit says.

"Uh-hu~~h. A widdle."

Oh man I can totally imagine Shinigami-sama somehow managing to sound like a sad little puppy when he says those lines.

Then he changes his tune. "Na~~h. It's not like that. Kid is already such a splendid shinigami. And when Kid becomes a complete shinigami, it won't matter whether I can move anymore or not, right?" Shinigami-sama cries a single, beautiful emo tear. "But lately Kid's eyes haven't been as cold as they used to be. That makes me impatient."

Oh Shinigami-sama, I love you. (*hugs*)

"When Kid became a real shinigami, he understood," Spirit says.

"Either way, I might not ever see his smiling face again..."

MEANWHILE!

Oh fuck, it's these assholes again.

And apparently Nu!Noah has ROCKET HANDS or some shit I dunno.

Anywhoo, Index is having some sort of breakdown and word-vomiting all over the page. "I WANT TO TEACH. I want to instruct. I want to profess. I WANT TO MAKE THEM KNOW. I want to coach. I want to educate. I WANT TO SHOW THEM. I want to guide them. I want them to learn. I want to edify. I WANT TO EXPLAIN. I want to inform. I want to enlighten. I want to guide them. In other words," Index says, "I WANT TO TEACH."

Geez, Ohkubo, did you give your thesaurus enough of a workout this month, or what?

"The BREW is mine," Index goes on. Hey, something else that everybody else in this manga seems to not care about anymore! "If I can utilize the kishin's insanity, I can force Eibon's great knowledge to spread..."

Sure. Okay. That plan makes perfect sense and isn't illogical (not to mention fairly boring and anti-climatic sounding) AT ALL.

Meanwhile! "HEY, YOU LITTLE SHIT!!" Noah shouts. "ARE YOU FUCKING KEEPIN' UP WITH ME OR WHAT?!"

"Yes! I'm only three wing-flaps behind you, Noah-sama!"

"I CAN'T HEAAAAAAAAAAR YOU!!"

"Yes! I'm only three wing-flaps behind you, Noah-sama!"

Well, that was certainly not a completely pointless and unfunny interlude. Darnit, Waffles, usually we can COUNT on you to provide epic hilarity! I guess this must have been your off-chapter, though. But that's okay. Brush it off, kid, brush it off. But we're definitely counting on you to be actually funny the next time that you appear, so don't let us down, okay?

Meanwhile, Maka is tired and sweaty!

"Are you okay?" Soul asks her. "Maka..."

"I'm okay," Maka says. "It was just kind of a shock to suddenly feel the wavelength of the kishin's insanity like that. And in the end, we still didn't find Crona..."

"We should stop searching for Crona today," Soul says.

Maka glares up at the moon.

And Justin leers right down back at her. I guess his face is always going to be like that now. "They found us..."

NEXT MONTH: COLOR ILLUSTRATION!

Also, that is the end of this month's chapter.





So, you know. PACING, MOTHERFUCKERS. It's the one thing that Ohkubo is fairly terrible with, and this chapter was a pretty perfect example of that. Last month I was scratching my head and wondering where the hell any sort of resolution to the Fyodor and Tsar business - which would only have taken a single line of dialogue, as it did in this chapter - was, as well as where the hell any sort of believable emotional reaction from Maka re: the news about Crona was. And then we got it in this chapter. But it was jarring, discordant, and weird to have that whaling business stuck in there (as awesome as the whaling business was) without first seeing and hearing the stuff that we finally got to see and hear in this chapter.

Which is really the pattern with Ohkubo. Kid gets kidnapped by a terrifying villain? Nobody has any sort of emotional reaction until several months after the fact. Justin goes insane? The only person who seems to even care is Tezca, and we don't see his reaction until half a year after the fact. Black Star finds out that Crona is crazypants and has grown a third arm? Maka doesn't react until three chapters after the fact. Maka finds out that Crona murdered an entire city full of people? Emotional reaction four months after the fact. Tezca murdered? I'm sure that somebody will express an emotional reaction to this in either November or December.

Of course Ohkubo doesn't do this all the time. But the times that he actually shows timely fallout from major Oh Shit moments - i.e. Asura's resurrection, BJ's murder, Kim's defection, Crona's first disappearance, etc. etc. - it only serves to highlight how weird it is for readers to NOT see those believable emotional reactions immediately in reaction to the event, rather than after two or three months of lighthearted side missions and practice flying or whatnot.

In short: PACING, IT MATTERS.

Which is my only real complaint about this chapter - that a few things that we saw this month we should have seen or heard last month - and no matter which plot thread next month's chapter picks up on, it's definitely going to be a good one.

Unless we re-visit Noah and Waffles and they turn out to be boring and unfunny again.

Siiiiiiigh.



ETA: Hey anonymice! Remember that this is a public post and that linking to scans (or scanslations) is against livejournal's TOS. If your comment contains a link to a scanslation, it will NOT be unscreened. Right now there are actually three of you (!!) who have submitted comments with links to scanslations in them, so that's why your comments haven't been unscreened. You're welcome to comment again without the links, though.

Also, yes, we know that in chapter 79 Justin was praying to God and looking up at the moon at the same time. This was pointed out repeatedly in the comments last month. ^^;;

[identity profile] titangirl161.livejournal.com 2011-08-11 11:49 pm (UTC)(link)
Oh the wonders of this chapter!

First off, another epically awkward sentance because Ohkubo likes to make sucky sentance FTW! (and so we don't make about 500 comments like last time, I'll clarify now: ""That's right," Shinigami-sama says. "If there ends up being a battle on the moon, it will inevitably turn into an aerial battle---... So we're gonna need Kid's skateboard-fu." Yes, he really said that. That's the closest English equivalent I can give you of Kid no skateboard-teku. Maybe "skateboard-no-jutsu" if you want to get really silly with the translation.")

Second...the moon? And of course Maka's finding it overshawdows Tezca's freaky soul and dying to figure it out...damn, poor Tezca, but it seems Ohkubo is really doing everything to keep him around, even making his soul still appear. Also, shinigami-sama seems to be fazed by ABSOLUTELY NOTHING...except the fact that his "little" Kid is all grown up. Im halfway between "D'awwww" and vomiting.

Thrid, does anybody really care about index? I don't...and I don't want him to keep coming back, but seems no one careas about what i think anyway...I don't think Ohkubo cares about what anyone thinks, though

And while this is a side note, seriously, WTF is up with the moon? DUDE, he NEEDS to go see a dentist. He CAN'T let that gingivitis go untreated, until blood is dripping out of your mouth through your teeth. Seriously, the moon has some mad bad gingivitis, I can't see it being any other reason why that would happen.

Thanks for the spoilers!

PS- I'm actually the first this time? Amazing...this is a first (bad pun FTW lol)

Yay for Harvar

(Anonymous) 2011-08-12 12:01 am (UTC)(link)
Harvar appeared and spoke some lines. That is enough for me--I love this chapter already.
ext_6355: (Default)

[identity profile] nenena.livejournal.com 2011-08-12 12:02 am (UTC)(link)
First off, another epically awkward sentance because Ohkubo likes to make sucky sentance FTW!

Whoa! I didn't think that sentence was awkward at all. It's Ohkubo doing wordplay and I happen to find it pretty darn clever and fun; it's just hard to translate into something that makes sense in English yet still captures the Ohkubo-ness of the Japanese.

[identity profile] vega-jd.livejournal.com 2011-08-12 12:17 am (UTC)(link)
Thank you so much for the recap!!! I saw the raw and got the impression that something important was happening but I couldn't tell what xD

I actually expected the chapter to be about Noah and Waffles for some obscure reason, but I was pleasantly surprised to learn that everyone shows up!! (except for Eruka because she apparently died or moved to Europe off-screen or something).

Bwaaahh Shinigami-sama is gonna die/disappear/ascend to a higher plane T_T I don't want any of the main characters to die *whines* I'm going to try to trust Ohkubo on this one arc, I want to believe that it will be epic and awesome and actually plot relevant. Ohkubo if you disappoint me I will cry manly tears.

Speaking of manly, was there a little heart above Soul and Kid's brofist or was it just me? xD
ext_6355: (Default)

[identity profile] nenena.livejournal.com 2011-08-12 12:23 am (UTC)(link)
Speaking of manly, was there a little heart above Soul and Kid's brofist or was it just me?

That's actually a highly stylized sound effect ("do" which is kind of like "bonk"), but now that you mention it, it does look an awful lot like a heart...

[identity profile] vega-jd.livejournal.com 2011-08-12 12:30 am (UTC)(link)
Oh I see, thanks for clearing that up for me! :) I guess I've seen enough bromance lately to believe anything xD

[identity profile] chiikaboom.livejournal.com 2011-08-12 12:38 am (UTC)(link)
Thanks for the recap!

Even though the Nu!Noah and Waffles exchange was completely and entirely pointless, I found it amusing. And the fist bump was hnnnggg. Its nice to see some Daddy angst though, here's hoping it actually leads to you know... development and shit.

Just watch, Kidd will die fighting the kishin and we'll get an emotional response 6 months later. Thats pro pacing right there d('-'d)

And Liz had a line in this chapter. Yaaaaay~

[identity profile] popcorn42.livejournal.com 2011-08-12 01:25 am (UTC)(link)
Part of me agrees with your complaint over the pacing whilst the other part is just so happy to have something 'happening' that he kinda doesn't care. XD

Also shame, we might not get to see Tezca's actual face after all. \:

[identity profile] primi-chan.livejournal.com 2011-08-12 02:09 am (UTC)(link)
Well, certainly wasn't disappointed with this chapter, which makes me happy since this month has been the best our of the rest of my summer vacation. The pacing could definitely use some work.

So nice to see that the predictions were right and that Asura's up on the moon raving with Justin, the clowns and the Space Core, and then there'll be a final battle in zero gravity like in Dead Space. And although I'll admit, seeing a floating island or something in the sky would've also been pretty sweet.

Another prediction I've got is that since we're getting to the finale of SE pretty much, Kidd will probably end up dying in the battle, be revived, go God Tier complete his Sanzu lines and then absolutely kick ass. Whoopde-fucking-do. And we'll probably see switches between the Asura battle and the Chrona battle and then for all we know we may have a Deus Ex Machina where when the Kishin is defeated, Chrona switches back to normal.

But that's just my theory, judging by Ohkubo's consistancy issues. Maybe we won't be disappointed.

Best part of the chapter was Maka getting splattered with blood from our favorite dental care deprived moon.

Thanks for the recap!
Edited 2011-08-12 02:12 (UTC)

(Anonymous) 2011-08-12 03:46 am (UTC)(link)
I liked this chapter, I really did. We got all those little (but distracting) bits of information about what Crona did out of the way, and we got Big Daddy show'in some love, which is always welcome! I really appreciated that little fist bump scene, my brother has OCD and I do my best to deal with his little rituals like that all the time, so I don't know, I just enjoyed Soul Obliging like that. I really loved the layout of the page when Maka was looking for Crona and we see Crona's smiling face, then Maka staring daggers, then batshit crazy Crona, then super serious Maka eyes. It was just really pleasing to look at and rather dramatic and sad. I'm getting nervous wondering what's going to happen to Crona. =/ I mean, I doubt Maka can just win him/her back with a hug, she's really going to have to dig down deep into Crona's psyche if she thinks she can save him. I'm very glad most of the members of Spartoi seem to still want to save Crona, and that it's implied Big Daddy's still holding out hope that there are other means to deal with Crona besides outright killing hir. It's still probably going to be tragic. (Btw, do you know if ALL of the Spartoi members [besides our beloved Troika] are going on the Crona mission? It wasn't too clear to me.) Oh, and Tezca! Jesus Tezca! (I may be in the minority, but I thought he looked awesome.) I hope he never takes off his bear head now, less vomiting ensue. What the hell's going to happen to Enrique? I didn't even see him in this chapter! Could he be plotting something...? Or did Ohkubo just forget to draw him again :( I hope he pops out in a time of crisis, like in chapter 60.... Also, where's Free? Is Crona in charge of Medusa's lackies now? (Because that would be hilarious.) Oh yeah, and Index is dissapoint.

Thank you so so much for the recap! I think their they're hilarious! Never stop!

[identity profile] rojeru.livejournal.com 2011-08-12 03:46 am (UTC)(link)
Finally! Things concerning the kishin are finally moving XD Tezca's death is confirmed, Tsar and Fyodor's death is confirmed (I vaguely recall Maka saying that there's a living soul inside those black balls), Nu!Noah and Waffles, as well as Index and the Brew appeared which could mean that Ohkubo hasn't forgotten about them after all (but I'm not holding me breath for it) XD

I already got used to the pacing and the late-reaction thing that it doesn't bother me anymore, though it would be better if Ohkubo would address that XD

Oh! And the one thing I've always asked myself has finally been answered!

It is possible for the moon's blood to drop on someone XD

Anyways, thank you so much for the recap =D

[identity profile] shinigamishi.livejournal.com 2011-08-12 04:13 am (UTC)(link)
Plot! Plot! PLOTTTT YAAAAY

Wait.

Maka is ordered to execute Crona? Emotional reaction two months after the fact.

Did I zone out and totally miss a chapter or something?

THE MOON'S BLOOD CAN INTERACT WITH PEOPLE NOW? WHOOO YES.

Oh god, the situation with Crona is fueling my Silent Hill/Soul Eater crossover so hard.

And holy crap, whole-world Soul Perception? Way to be the human radar, Maka. Way to go. That's got to be kind of intimidating deep down.

Now if I can just get the RAWs somehow...

Thanks for your recap!

[identity profile] xaliceunknownx.livejournal.com 2011-08-12 04:43 am (UTC)(link)
Waitwaitwaitwoahwoahwait. Woah. Back up a second.

" 'Kid should be taken off the Spartoi's current mission and join the battle against the kishin' "

WHAT?

Okay. I love Kid. I mean I LOVE Kid. I don't know why. Actually, scratch that. I love anime!Kid, who always seemed able to kick some ass during missions with *style*. And that his weakness was symmetry somehow made him feel more epic. And, okay, I kinda have the hots for Miyano Mamoru and his voice acting.

And then I read the manga, and his cool factor just kept dropping lower and lower. For me, the best thing about Kid happened *just this chapter* when he said, "If I die, then Black Star is going to be pretty pissed off at me" because I'm a big Kid/BlackStar shipper and this line can just be taken in such a good way in itself. (For example, Kid could have continued with saying something along the lines of "…because I promised him that I'd give myself away to him, and we were really thinking that once this whole goddamn Chrona/Asura/Noah thing was over, we'd get around to it." A fangirl can only dream.)

Anyway. I just think it'd be ridiculous to bring Kid out of the big three. I thought it had been established many times in the manga how 'Maka Albarn is too big of a threat to witches AND THE KISHIN ASURA'. I'm sure I must be misunderstanding something. Yeah, never mind, I'm sure I am. I have to be.

But to even want to bring Kid over BlackStar……………..I actually really like BlackStar, and I think now that he has his shit together about why he seeks 'power', he could really do some good. I don't know. That's just me. BlackStar can run through (multiple) walls without feeling a thing, move at the speed of light, and use shadows as weapons, not to mention use his soul wavelength as an attack. And Kid can go 'pew pew!' with his demon guns. And, should he be inclined to culinary, make the worlds most symmetrical crepe or something, I really don't know.

*sigh* I just wasted ten minutes writing that…………

All that being said, I find it extremely hilarious that it's so much easier to find the *Kishin Asura* than Chrona. I don't know. I thought it was worth a good "HA! XD" out loud.


Well, this has been a very good birthday present! ^________^ Thank you so much for the translation! It was so exciting for this to come out on my birthday~! :D
ext_6355: (Default)

[identity profile] nenena.livejournal.com 2011-08-12 05:02 am (UTC)(link)
I vaguely recall Maka saying that there's a living soul inside those black balls

She did, and that's why she and Soul tried to save them. But I guess there's no hope of saving them anymore, since Kid is counting them as "murdered." But that's why I said that they got a fate worse than death rather than straight-up death. (*shudder*)

Anyways, thank you so much for the recap =D

You're welcome!
ext_6355: (Default)

[identity profile] nenena.livejournal.com 2011-08-12 05:17 am (UTC)(link)
I thought it had been established many times in the manga how 'Maka Albarn is too big of a threat to witches AND THE KISHIN ASURA'. I'm sure I must be misunderstanding something. Yeah, never mind, I'm sure I am. I have to be.

You are.

Maka was only a threat to the kishin because he was afraid that she could find his hiding place. That's the sole reason that Justin wanted to eliminate Maka. It was stated over and over again. Maka has never been established as a threat against the kishin in terms of her fighting ability; the only reason he was afraid of her is because she could find his location.

And then she, you know, did. So the threat has already been carried out. The kishin has no more reason to fear Maka.

Also I think it would have been pretty clear at this point at Kid's major battle is against Asura and that Maka's ultimate personal challenge is going to be Crona. That's been foreshadowed rather less-than-subtly for a while now.

Although Black Star could still go either way. And I wouldn't be surprised is he ditched the Crona battle and ended up fighting alongside Kid in the end.

Thank you so much for the translation! It was so exciting for this to come out on my birthday~! :D

You're welcome, and happy birthday!
ext_6355: (Default)

[identity profile] nenena.livejournal.com 2011-08-12 05:24 am (UTC)(link)
Did I zone out and totally miss a chapter or something?

You didn't, I was confusing one event for another. I was thinking of Maka being told that Crona had murdered an entire city but for some reason I wrote down the death sentence instead.

Thanks for your recap!

You're welcome!

[identity profile] xaliceunknownx.livejournal.com 2011-08-12 05:52 am (UTC)(link)
Ahhh, okay! I knew I was missing something. I think I also kinda confused it with the anime a little. Just how everyone was saying "It's up to Maka now" when the Kishin built that……..dome, and Maka got in. Ughh……I also need sleep. I very much need sleep. And food.

I get that Kid's major battle should be Asura because he's a shinigami, but………….I just don't know. I don't think he's really come as far as BlackStar or Maka in terms of personal growth. I still feel like………..I don't know, he was the same from the beginning. He can still do big power-ups and all, but he could do that from the very beginning. Connecting the Sanzou(sp? I so don't know right now =__=) Lines is pretty much the only thing I feel he has going for him. Unless he and Asura have some deep talk about morals.

……….It'll probably end up being a combination of both.

I don't know. I think the biggest thing that challenged Kid was when he began to question whether or not his father was the source of all madness.

(On another note that I forgot to mention, oh my god, Harvar got a whole goddamn *monologue*. You go Harvar. That was more speech than he's had in every other chapter combined. Unless I'm forgetting something, which is highly likely, as I feel like I'm about to pass out.)

Thanks for the happy birthday and oh god i can't type anymore words…………..*falls asleep* (-,-)

[identity profile] twipire.livejournal.com 2011-08-12 06:03 am (UTC)(link)
Sorry! I had to delete my comment and re-write, simply because I have a tendancy to think of what I wanted to say conveniently after I've already submitted some vague, five word reply.

Anyway, I'll begin with a question or two.

I didn't really understand what Shini-sama meant when he explained to Spirit why he was impatient(eye's weren't cold or something...?) Apologies- It's too late in the evening for me to make sense of particular word sentences, it seems...Sorry if it's just me being ignoramus!

Another thing- Since Noah #1 was apparently greed, is it possible this one is wrath? He's sounds awfully pissed.

Then again....

Perhaps it's just because he's as successful a villian as the incredible hulk is a ballerina. Maybe even less so. So...the fact he was 'greed' before has really no relevance? Actually, even if he was indeed wrath...I'm not even sure that would be relevant.

Thank you for the great recap~!

[identity profile] twipire.livejournal.com 2011-08-12 06:17 am (UTC)(link)
My goodness, I was thinking the same thing since the anime ended. Where does the moon's blood dribble go? It can actually land on you, if you're not careful. x3
ext_6355: (Default)

[identity profile] nenena.livejournal.com 2011-08-12 06:24 am (UTC)(link)
I didn't really understand what Shini-sama meant when he explained to Spirit why he was impatient(eye's weren't cold or something...?) Apologies- It's too late in the evening for me to make sense of particular word sentences, it seems...Sorry if it's just me being ignoramus!

No need to apologize, Ohkubo was being pretty coy with that line anyway. I interpreted it to mean that Shini is impatient waiting for Kid to become a full shinigami, because his eyes indicate that Kid is developing a lot of the qualities that would make him a good shinigami - namely compassion, and ability to work well with weapons and other meisters, a more balanced view of the universe, etc. And that Shini is probably impatient because he knows that he doesn't have much longer to hang around and he wants Kid to take the reigns for both personal reasons (because he's a father and he wants to be there to witness his son finally coming of age) and also for godly reasons (because the world needs a shinigami like Kid).

Another thing- Since Noah #1 was apparently greed, is it possible this one is wrath? He's sounds awfully pissed.

Yes, he's wrath. That was established over a year ago. 0.o;;

So...the fact he was 'greed' before has really no relevance?

No, it's relevant. Kid hypothesized that Index created the Greed Noah so that Noah would eventually collect the BREW for him, remember?

Thank you for the great recap~!

You're welcome! ^__^

[identity profile] rojeru.livejournal.com 2011-08-12 06:26 am (UTC)(link)
Lol yeah XD I feel sorry for anyone who get hit by a big drop XD

(Anonymous) 2011-08-12 08:47 am (UTC)(link)
I love that the final showdown really is gonna be on the moon. XD And it's great that Maka was able to find the Kishin and all, but then really what was the point if Tezca was still able to relay the news? Poor Tezca died for no good reason. Lol Maka has the power of Cerebro now. And so Kid get's the honor of fighting the Kishin then.Uhh he's going with the other death scythes though right? Though he's sure to get the spotlight. I can't help feeling black star is gonna go fight with Kid though since last chapter established his way to pseudo fly, though of course in reality he couldn't survive space. Anyway either way seems the story is starting to wind down. I guess Not! will continue after the main series is done then. Can't wait for the awesome moon battle, and crona/maka fight! Thanks for the recap!

[identity profile] twipire.livejournal.com 2011-08-12 09:08 am (UTC)(link)
Oh dear god... A year ago? Where the heck was I? >////<

Anyway, thank you for clearing that up for me!

[identity profile] littlegal2008.livejournal.com 2011-08-12 10:28 am (UTC)(link)
This arc kind of feels like the last arc of the show, with Asura being spotted and Shibussen making their move as well as presumably Maka's and Crona's final confrontation.

Anyways thank you again for your wonderful summary!

[identity profile] hyatt-ayanami.livejournal.com 2011-08-12 12:58 pm (UTC)(link)
Thank you so much for your recap/translation!!!!♥
I agree so much,pacing in SE has always been slow,i still remember when Kid has been kidnapped,i always thought they acted as if they did not care at all XD
This chapter seems great,probably this is the final arc.
I see alot of emphasis on Kid ,i agree on the prediction that he will probably die...and be revived-maybe that's the final thing to become a complete shinigami.
And i'm so nervous about Chrona ;_; seriusly...i keep seeing her as a victim,hope there is still hope ;_;

Page 1 of 4